The Inevitable Shift From Excess Liquidity Will be Negative for Stocks
Despite persisting worldwide deflationary concerns, international commodity prices have risen sharply. Investment funds that have swollen as a result of monetary easing in Japan and the U.S. are flowing into commodity markets, while emerging economies, including China, that supply low-priced products are increasing demand for raw materials and food.
But rising prices of materials cause problems for economic policies intended to counter deflation as well as for consumers and companies.
Even the price of coffee, soy beans and other agricultural commodities is rising. Coffee rose as much as 16% in January alone. The U.S. Commodity Research Bureau's futures index for coffee, a benchmark price index for the commodity, posted the highest level in about 20 years in January.
TT's Take Money inflows into funds that invest mainly in commodity futures amounted to $6.6 billion in the January-September period of last year, according to TASS Research. The working balance for the funds doubled to $19.5 billion during the same nine month period. Money from Japanese pension funds and individual investors is also flowing into investment trusts that incorporate commodity funds. By comparison, speculators' outstanding purchase contracts at the NYMEX total about $4 billion each for crude oil and gold, a level that cannot be compared with the scale of the U.S. stock market, which exceeds $10 trillion in aggregate market value. Investment funds are increasingly flowing into commodities.
Secular bull trends in commodities are inevitably followed by higher interest rates, and higher interest rates inhibit stock market rallies, especially when the markets shift gears from excess liquidity to earnings or fundamentals. Commodity prices soared from the 1970s, which saw two oil crises, to the 1980s. In those days, dollar crises and inflation became chronic amid declining confidence in the U.S. economy. The current increase in commodity prices is occurring in a quite different situation, namely, deflation.
Growing supply pressures from developing countries are pushing down prices of products, the Fed and the Bank of Japan have placed emphasis on checking deflation. Money that has swollen due to monetary easing measures that run the risk of inflation is heading toward the commodity market. Given the severe competition among companies, it is not easy for them to pass increases in material costs on to product prices. In Japan's consumer price index surveys for December, prices that rose from a year earlier were all in regulated fields, such as medical care, education, and fuel, electricity and water charges. Prices of furniture, household goods, clothing and food declined despite rising raw material prices. Many U.S. companies are boosting their productivity by accelerating capital spending, mainly in IT, even though their capacity utilization rates are at the 70% level. Growth in supply capacity will help to curb inflation by causing an oversupply in facilities and employment, while monetary easing for preventing deflation will cause speculative funds to increase.
As soon as they are able, companies will begin pushing through higher basic materials prices into selling prices, leading to inflation, which in turn will mean higher interest rates. When that happens, equity markets will consolidate, and the interim consolidation could be nasty, at least in the short-term.
